Review
The Pauses
A Cautionary Tale

New Grenada (2011) Aaron H

The Pauses – A Cautionary Tale cover artwork
The Pauses – A Cautionary Tale — New Grenada, 2011

Remember when you were a little kid getting tucked into bed? Then someone would reach for a thin book with a shiny gold spine, and they would read you a bedtime story? Well, I don’t, but I certainly remember the books. It was my affinity for those books that drew me towards The Pause’s debut album, A Cautionary Tale, which is an exceptional Indie-Rock record with a cover that serves as an homage to Little Golden Books.

They open the album with arguably the best track, and one of the better Indie-Rock openers of the year, “Go North.” It’s a straightforward rock number harboring catchy riffs, beautiful harmonies, and topping it off with a subtle horn background in the bridge. It could be misleading though. Before you know it, they’re going to start diverting from that Rock sound beginning with the contrasting, “Beyond Bianca.” This track is slower paced—using synthesizers to produce an ominous opening. The song gets heavier as it progresses before an explosive outro. They keep the slower pace with, “The Migration,” and get even more diverse making the Rhodes piano the primary lead. After 2 slower tracks, you’d hope they would pick things back up. However, they do the opposite, and slow down the tempo more in the smoky number, “Pull the Pin.” They’ve brought back the Rhodes to create a real lounge-esque track with eerie harmonies—building up to another heavy rock outro, while Tierny Tough continues to sing with her soothing vocals.

The second half of the album starts off with the weakest song on A Cautionary Tale. The Pauses alter their direction a bit on, “The Leap Year,” by assembling a more electronic and program oriented song. It’s executed well, but it’s such a bore. Following is the beautifully orchestrated, “Hands Up.” They keep you on their road of change and progression utilizing more programming, but adding in violins and piano. I’m probably going way out of bounds, but it almost sounds as if they were influenced by Nine Inch Nails’, “Right Where It Belongs” or “The Great Below.” They start to pick things up before the album’s closer with, “Little Kids.” It’s the most upbeat song since the album’s opener. They come full circle by using nearly all the elements they picked up along the way for a more direct--but diverse--pop-rock song. They close the album with, “Goodbye, Winthorpe,” which is an instrumental track. It’s kept subtle and then builds into a monstrous jam session. Following 14 seconds of silence is a hidden track that really brings the album to a perfect close with an enchanting ukulele duet.

It may take a few listens to really acquire a taste for the sluggish feel of the record, but it’s worth it. The songwriting is top notch and considerably diverse. Although, more songs like, “Go North,” would have really benefitted the flow. J Robbins did a magnificent job on the production and the cover’s awesome. Hopefully, A Cautionary Tale and The Pauses will get the attention they deserve.

8.7 / 10Aaron H • March 25, 2011

The Pauses – A Cautionary Tale cover artwork
The Pauses – A Cautionary Tale — New Grenada, 2011

Related features

The Pauses

One Question Interviews • October 1, 2019

Related news

New from The Pauses

Posted in Bands on May 17, 2018

The Pauses Announce 'Interact-O-Vision' Tour

Posted in Tours on September 15, 2014

The Pauses and Great Deceivers making split

Posted in Bands on July 28, 2012

Recently-posted album reviews

Dream Fatigue

No Requiem
Daze (2026)

There’s a particular tension that makes alternative rock compelling. I love the emotional push and pull between softness and eruption. On No Requiem, Massachusetts outfit Dream Fatigue thrive in that space, crafting a seven song EP that balances dreamlike melody with bursts of distortion and emotional urgency. Born from the creative partnership between drummer Matt Wood and vocalist Jonali McFadden, … Read more

The Went Wrongs

This Isn't What I Ordered
Transcendental Revolution (2026)

I'm not sure what's happening to me in middle age. I used to find samples clever and a nice change-of-pace technique on albums. But lately I feel like they interrupt instead of compliment what I'm hearing. This Isn't What I Ordered starts off really strong with fast, melodic and personalized punk over the first few songs. Then the sound clips … Read more

Spillings

Spillings
The Garotte (2026)

Spillings is a minimalist reconfiguration undertaken by two artists whose careers have been about genre deconstruction. The paths of Mathieu Ball and Liam Andrews have been running on parallel tracks, but both have been aiming for a similar endpoint. That is to strip down the heavy, experimental rock form, while at the same time retaining its destabilizing core. With Big … Read more