Review
The New Dress
Where Our Failures Are

Red Leader (2007) Cory

The New Dress – Where Our Failures Are cover artwork
The New Dress – Where Our Failures Are — Red Leader, 2007

The New Dress certainly knows how to make a first impression. Twenty seconds into Where Our Failures Are the tandem sings out, "I'm setting of alarms and planning bombs instead of songs / And if the cops ask I'm their man!" The New Dress holds nothing back, singing stripped down folk-punk about socialism and society, covering Billy Brag and Ed Pickford, while still providing the personal effects to not make Where Our Failures Are a fully political album, but rather of two people unafraid to bare it all.

The New Dress is comprised of Laura Fidler and Bill Manning, both tackling vocals and Manning taking the acoustic and electric guitar. The New Dress could easily be a Plan-It-X band, as they play naked, raw folk punk with a focus on energy and passion rather than perfect melody. It's obvious that neither Manning nor Fidler are completely comfortable in their roles, unsure of their voices and abilities. But instead of detracting from the album, it only adds to it. After all, the album is called Where Our Failures Are, and the tandem have no problem putting them all on the table. It's not necessarily about the skill, but rather about the ability and the hope.

Both Fidler and Manning have rigid, raspy voices that help all to the overall feel of the album. That being said, their words are forceful, and while maybe not confident in their voices they are certainly confident in the message. In "Yeah But No," they state with certainty, "We'll overcome your fears and we'll become them," having no doubt that any problem they face will be dealt with and beaten back.

As stated above, what makes Where Our Failures Are recognizable is how personal and stripped down the album is. Essentially it's just two people and a guitar, with the feeling of no barrier in between the team of Fidler and Manning and the listener. "Wake Up," features Manning doing vocals by himself, his warbling voice reminiscent of a scared boy in front of his classmates, hoping he gets through the song without any slip ups. It's gut wrenching and admirable at the same time, but Manning probably wouldn't want it any other way. Fidler, while having a much more pure voice, is equally as personal, as she sings, "I know the way to my heart is through broken ribs."

While playing your simple folk punk chords, The New Dress proves that it is possible to create substantial without many materials. It's political, but more importantly it is honesty in the sense of the word, with no veils or curtains.

6.9 / 10Cory • February 3, 2008

The New Dress – Where Our Failures Are cover artwork
The New Dress – Where Our Failures Are — Red Leader, 2007

Recently-posted album reviews

Menace Ruine

The Color of the Grave Is Green
Union Finale Records (2025)

One of the most unique voices in extreme music, Menace Ruine stand out in their sonic evolution. The duo of Geneviève Beaulieu and Steve de la Moth started out in a raw, uncompromising fashion, merging black metal and industrial to create absolute havoc in Cult of Ruins and The Die is Cast. In the coming years, they would expand this … Read more

Extortionist

Stare Into The Seething Wounds
Unique Leader (2025)

With a band name like Extortionist, you instantly know they aren’t messing around. I’ve watched enough true crime documentaries to know when you’re going to get tangled up with someone you shouldn’t. Hailing from the Pacific Northwest, this band gives you exactly what you want and expect – raw, merciless and unforgiving music. Looking at the cover art and their … Read more

The Carolyn

Pyramid Scheme of Grief
59X, Disconnect/Disconnect (2025)

This is one of my "find" records of the year so far. I caught a few songs by The Carolyn at FEST 22 and that essentially put them on my radar, but a new record gets a band even more on my radar. But I've been struggling on how to describe The Carolyn. I'll start with "like The Lawrence Arms, … Read more