Review / 200 Words Or Less
The Midwestern
The Midwestern

Rorschach (2007) Scottie

The Midwestern – The Midwestern cover artwork
The Midwestern – The Midwestern — Rorschach, 2007

This is what happens when a band has yet to find its style. What we have here is some decent songwriting that comes off as underdeveloped. The track "Molsen Golden" starts as a respectable jam with enough intricacy and tempo changes to call back memories of The Cancer Conspiracy and the forefathers of the style, King Crimson. Halfway through the track, the song reverts to simple riffing, sounding more like an un-mastered demo waiting for the vocals to be added. This undecided style continues onto another track while the other two songs have sparse vocal parts. It almost seems that the band is trying to use the vocal melody as another instrument. If the disc contained more than four songs, we might have a clearer understanding of what the band's vision is, but based on this EP I'm thinking they may be asking the same question.

6.0 / 10Scottie • November 8, 2007

The Midwestern – The Midwestern cover artwork
The Midwestern – The Midwestern — Rorschach, 2007

Recently-posted album reviews

Silver Proof

Even If It Hurts
Independent (2026)

Some pop punk records feel made for playlists and algorithms. They’re polished into oblivion, emotionally vague, and afraid to get messy. Silver Proof clearly didn’t get that memo. The Buffalo trio’s debut full length, Even If It Hurts, leans heavily into the emotional core of early 2010s emo pop and melody while still sounding energized rather than nostalgic. Across the … Read more

Lice (Aesop Rock & Homeboy Sandman)

Vol. 4: Miami Lice
Rhymesayers (2026)

This EP released kind of suddenly, back in March, right before a bunch of stuff hit the fan in my life outside of SPB. Which means the EP felt sudden, but this review has been stewing for nearly three months with a lot of repeat listening along the journey. At eight songs in length, it's short but sweet, and as … Read more

Various Artists

There Is No Sun - A Tribute To Jay Reatard
Sonic Church (2026)

The late, great Jay Reatard was a prolific master of rock n roll gems. Whether it be with his earlier budget-punk act of his namesake, Reatards, his synth-punk projects Lost Sounds and Angry Angles, or his solo material as Jay Reatard, Jimmy Lee Lindsey Jr. was an incredible songwriter. Those aforementioned bands are just a smattering of units he’s been … Read more