Review
The Keystone Kids
Things Get Shaky

Deep Elm (2012) Aaron H

The Keystone Kids – Things Get Shaky cover artwork
The Keystone Kids – Things Get Shaky — Deep Elm, 2012


Half of The Keystone Kids is half of Slingshot Dakota, while the other half is Ryan O'Donnell of Yo Man Go, and that was enough to hook and reel me in. While both share Carly Comando's soothing vocals and keys, each one is on the opposite side of the indie spectrum. The Keystone Kids verges more on the electro-pop side rather than the punk. Things Get Shaky provide seven catchy tunes, but I'm not sure it was enough.

The opening track, "Crumble," is pretty mid-tempo--as is most of the album. It's mostly Carly singing along to her piano with Ryan strumming along. It hints at a larger sounding record ahead of it, but the following track, "Mouth," dumbs it down with a bit more programmed beats and synth. The track comes off dry without really feeling full until the end. O'Donnell takes the lead on, "What They're Saying," which has the band sounding more like The Postal Service. It's more upbeat but maintains the same tempo as the previous.

The duo shares duties on, "Falling." While it keeps the slow pace, it's a much stronger track than, "Mouth" and "What They're Saying." Carly comes out with the well orchestrated piano playing and both add a little force to the track in the chorus. With what it seems like the two are trying to do with this project--they accomplish it best on "Up all Night." They bring about a more electro-clash style that holds your attention more than the earlier synth-pop tracks. It's more urgent and dance-worthy.

We get closer to the end with, "Miles." It's the perfect night time driving track. The production is a little bit more crisp compared to the other tracks. It's another track that does away with the synth-pop and keeps it more stripped down and moving. The same goes for the album's closer, "44." Ryan closes out the album with a more emotional performance. However, the main problem with the track is it's too short. It comes to an end without really giving you closure.

Things Get Shaky is an odd album when it comes to length. It feels too long to be an EP but too short to be considered a full LP. The album could have benefited from another song or 2. While the synthier tracks blend in well enough, The Keystone Kids' bread and butter are the more stripped down songs. It's catchy enough to have grabbed my attention, but whether or not it'll hold my attention is a different story.

7.0 / 10Aaron H • September 14, 2012

The Keystone Kids – Things Get Shaky cover artwork
The Keystone Kids – Things Get Shaky — Deep Elm, 2012

Related news

Deep Elm reduces e-prices

Posted in Labels on October 7, 2012

Advertisement

DCxPC 2025

Recently-posted album reviews

Gus Baldwin & The Sketch

The Sketch
Permanent Teeth (2025)

When The Sketch opens, I find myself quickly thinking of “Got The Time” by Joe Jackson. For the most part, that comparison fades by the time the power chords kick in at 10 seconds, but I also bring it up because (at least in my mind) that’s a classic track that doesn’t get enough fanfare. No artist wants constant “sounds … Read more

Chat Pile

Cool World
Flenser (2024)

The great American experiment has a wide range of experiences, but it tends to focus on the coasts. There are countless dystopian pieces of art, often culling from a Warriors-esque concept of urban grit. Chat Pile play dystopian, brutal noise-punk, but from a distinctly middle American point of view where instead of civilians shadowed under dense skylines, their anonymity instead … Read more

The Anomalys

Down The Hole
Slovenly (2024)

If I have to give the elevator pitch, I’ll call The Anomalys garage rock with an ear for surf and psyche rock -- turned up to 11 and blasted through blown out speakers in an old 1980s sedan. It’s high-energy, no-frills rock ‘n’ roll with attitude. While it’s short, loud and fast, there’s also quite a bit of nuance and … Read more