Review
The Ergs!
That's It...Bye

Don Giovanni (2009) Loren

The Ergs! – That's It...Bye cover artwork
The Ergs! – That's It...Bye — Don Giovanni, 2009

Bands break up all the time. Sometimes they blow up on stage, storm off from a tour, grow apart, and on occasion they cordially agree that it's time to move on. In any case, they almost always leave fans wanting more. The Ergs! decided to hand one to their fans, announcing their decision ahead of time and releasing a 12" single to give fans one last piece of wax. That's It

Bye is the band's swan song, delivering three quick, poppy, and Descendents-heavy jams.

If you haven't heard the band, it's time you check them out. The single is a solid representation of what the band does, but I'd have to point towards a full length if you have the money to spare. With the opener, "Anthem for a New Amanda," singing drummer Mikey jumps in with powerful melodies and an emotional delivery. His voice walks a fine line between four-eyed nerd and snotty punker. This song is really held together by the rhythm section. Jeff offers some nice hooks and a solo, but the prominent basslines from Joe Keller really carry the energy. And, yes, with a fiancé named Amanda there's a little more for me to dig about the song, even if it's not remotely personal to me.

"

And the True Believers" is another Descendents-style song with a strong rhythm, a little more guitar in the mix than the previous song, and clear, emotive vocals from Mikey. He's got a knack for delivering his lyrics as catchy as possible. Something that strikes me about The Ergs! is, despite their poppy nature, they rarely use backing vocals. As Mikey repeats the chorus over the last few seconds of the song, the heart-on-sleeve conveyance comes across more personally without the others chiming in with harmonies.

"Piltdown Man" is a bit more of a guitar track with Jeff taking over the singing, with a shaky voice and some background "ahhs." Again, one of the band's strengths lies in their ability to make vocal melody while keeping up the steady Ramones-punk beat and doing so without succumbing to chanting slogans. Jeff does an admirable job with this song and it's among my favorites I've heard with him at the helm.

And, in eight short minutes, that's it. This record feels like it's over too fast, much like the band...and I want more.

8.5 / 10Loren • April 21, 2009

The Ergs! – That's It...Bye cover artwork
The Ergs! – That's It...Bye — Don Giovanni, 2009

Related features

Mikey Erg

One Question Interviews • March 10, 2015

Don Giovanni Records: History 101

Music / History 101 • December 16, 2013

The Ergs!

Interviews

Related news

20 year edition of dorkrockcorkrod

Posted in Records on March 14, 2024

More The Ergs! reviews

The Ergs!

Jersey's Best Prancers
Don Giovanni (2006)

Anyone who's been paying attention can see the writing on the wall: like Cock Sparrer in 1982, pop punk's coming back. Of course, it never really left; it's just seen a variety of mutations since the halcyon days of "Locket Love": The Descendents' heartsick catharsis, The Lillingtons' television city dreaming, and the thrift store angst of Saves the Day are … Read more

The Ergs!

Upstairs/Downstairs
Dirtnap (2007)

The Ergs are self-proclaimed dorks. The great thing is that they are dorks that can write some great hooks. Upstairs/Downstairs is simply The Ergs latest example to demonstrate their ability to write infectious songs about girls and other pop-punk staple subjects. Upstairs/Downstairs delivers where their debut full length, dorkrockcockrod, set the stage for and where last year's EP, Jersey's Best … Read more

The Ergs!

The Time And The Season EP
Dirtnap (2022)

If you’ve been waiting years to hear Mikey Erg ask, “Who’s your daddy,” well, you’re in luck. The band is back with their first new material since 2016 – having only released a 2016 EP since their initial 2008 breakup. This time it’s a four song EP titled Time and the Season, named after their cover of The Zombies’ hit … Read more