Review
The Casting Out
Go Crazy! Throw Fireworks!

Fail Safe (2009) Jason

The Casting Out – Go Crazy! Throw Fireworks! cover artwork
The Casting Out – Go Crazy! Throw Fireworks! — Fail Safe, 2009

Nathan Gray was the lead singer of what was one of the most important band in the late 90's, Boy Sets Fire. There are plenty of people out there that would just love to refute this fact. Nevertheless from Boy Sets Fire's performance at More than Music where they had members of the audience come up and talk about being sexually violated to their never ending battle with Conquer the World Records to finally "selling out" and going to Victory there was no other band that was constantly on the lips of those in the know during the last decade. Unfortunately Boy Sets Fire faded to obscurity by signing to the same label as Creed (Creed!) and putting out a near nu-metal album and then were dropped like it was hot. Boy Sets Fire quickly resurfaced on Equal Vision with an album that included horns which no one really liked. Boy Sets Fire called it a day shortly after.

Don't fret though, Gray is back with The Casting Out and still singing about screaming and redemption or screaming for redemption. However, this time he's backed with some new people who happen to know how to write a really good head bopping rock song versus brooding melodic screamed/sung hardcore that Boy Sets Fire practically invented. Imagine Boy Sets Fire having a lot of fun with their songs. There isn't a song on Go Crazy! Throw Fireworks! that I can't imagine Gray smiling during, even during slower tracks like "The Ebbing of the Tide."

So if anything Go Crazy! Throw Fireworks! is a fun listen of memorable hooks and catchy choruses that you will get stunk in your skull for days on end. Boy Sets Fire also had a lot of memorable songs that suction cupped their way to your brain. However they were very angry, brooding, political, and overwrought with almost every emotion in the book. The Casting Out come at with songs that come off as more of a wink and smirk rather than a brow beating. Go Crazy! Throw Fireworks! is good album filled with speedy near pop-punk moments that luckily doesn't get too goofy. If I had to classify The Casting Out as anything I would call them melodic hardcore for the over-thirty set that doesn't spend their time at shows stagediving anymore. Nope, we uhh, they now just stand in the back, laughing nostalgically at the kids moshing while bobbing their heads in time. Maybe they remember a time when a band could mean the world to them and possibly everyone else. By the way, I dare you not to clap along with "These Alterations," you won't be able to.

8.8 / 10Jason • June 1, 2009

The Casting Out – Go Crazy! Throw Fireworks! cover artwork
The Casting Out – Go Crazy! Throw Fireworks! — Fail Safe, 2009

Related news

The Casting Out going on indefinite hiatus

Posted in Splits on October 1, 2010

The Casting Out Recording New LP

Posted in Bands on February 4, 2010

Eyeball Signs The Casting Out

Posted in Labels on January 6, 2010

Recently-posted album reviews

Alien Nosejob

How A Mosquito Operates
Anti Fade, Iron Lung (2026)

The one-man band of Alien Nosejob continues to crank out short, angry hardcore in quick bursts. I've lost count of how many records Jake Robertson has now released under the name. I'll just say that while the first couple took some direction changes, the project seems to have found its footing in 1980s-influenced hardcore. With 17 songs in 24 minutes, … Read more

Cancer Bats

Give Me Dirt
Marshall Amplification PLC, New Damage records (2026)

ALBUM HIGHLIGHTS – “Bright Eyes of Gold”, “Give Me Dirt”, “Long Tooth”, “Fools Like You” Almost exactly two years ago, on 8th August 2024, Cancer Bats played Conne Island in Leipzig – a choice they would live to regret. Unbeknownst to them at the time, the centre had slowly become renowned for its radical politics and, more recently, the ban … Read more

Tyler Sonnichsen

The Dead Milkmen
J-Card Press (2026)

When I saw The Dead Milkmen at Toronto’s Diamond Club back in the late 1980s, the floor was a volatile, beautiful mess of colliding subcultures. It was like different species of house flies bumping into one another, wondering what the hell you were doing in the mason jar. You had suburban high school pocket-pen-protector pencil-neck nubile nerds, college radio snobs … Read more