Review / 200 Words Or Less
Swallow The Sun
Emerald Forest & The Blackbird

Spinefarm Records (2012) Sarah

Swallow The Sun – Emerald Forest & The Blackbird cover artwork
Swallow The Sun – Emerald Forest & The Blackbird — Spinefarm Records, 2012

Swallow the Sun may have gotten into the death-doom metal craze a good decade after its peak, but even thirteen years on, they are still going strong, evidenced by their latest release, 2012's Emerald Forest and the Blackbird.

At the core of the album are its meandering trips through doom metal, with hints of gothic metal and melodeath supplied liberally. The extended, repetitious passages also suggest some influences from post-metal, though without the tendency towards sludge. The occasional peppering of spoken word and female vocals also adds some variety here and there, but don't expect them to deviate too far from the norm.

There's no implication that Swallow the Sun aren't still a strong act, but Emerald Forest does show their age. It drags on a bit, especially towards the second half. This isn't exactly a surprise when you consider that the album consists of ten similarly-styled pieces, all longer than your average metal track, but it still makes for a somewhat sluggish finish to an album that's actually pretty tight otherwise.

If you enjoy more pensive metal, then you'll love Emerald Forest. But if you're new to the band, consider their stronger debut, 2003's The Morning Never Came instead.

7.0 / 10Sarah • March 19, 2013

Swallow The Sun – Emerald Forest & The Blackbird cover artwork
Swallow The Sun – Emerald Forest & The Blackbird — Spinefarm Records, 2012

Related news

Swallow the Sun releases new record

Posted in MP3s on September 12, 2012

Swallow the Sun in North America

Posted in Tours on May 28, 2012

Katatonia, Swallow The Sun tour

Posted in Tours on April 13, 2010

Recently-posted album reviews

Lethal Limits

Elevate EP
GhettoBlaster Productions (2025)

As far as I can gather Jeff Corso has been playing in bands in the Bay Area for the past 20 years but seems like exclusively hardcore until now. Full disclosure: I’m only reviewing this because Aesop from Hickey plays drums. That said, I generally only review stuff I like, so go figure. This doesn’t sound like Hickey but since … Read more

Dealbreaker

New Sides
Late Again Records, Toll Free Records (2026)

Dealbreaker popped onto my radar as part of a package tour with Pro Wrestling, who cold called me with a Penske File namedrop. This story is a bit of a Canadian roundabout, but their methodology worked: I listened to their music and dug it enough to review it. And I'm mentioning it because, at times, Dealbreaker reminds me of The … Read more

The Library Is On Fire

Degeneration Elegies
The Abyss, Ltd. (2026)

There’s a certain kind of band that never quite fits the moment they arrive in. Sometimes too jagged for one scene, too melodic for another. The Library Is On Fire were one of those bands in the early 2000s, hovering somewhere between indie-punk urgency and power-pop instinct without fully settling into either. On Degeneration Elegies, their first full-length in over … Read more