Review
Smother Party
Casa Limon

Variant (2011) — Cheryl

Smother Party – Casa Limon cover artwork
Smother Party – Casa Limon — Variant, 2011

Brooklyn's Smother Party come armed with an intriguing name and an interesting sound. Apparently gaining the band name from an old English custom of literally covering bedridden family members with mattresses and, well, smothering them. This loving ritual was deemed "a smother party." How perfectly morbid. It's the fascinating nom de plume that piqued my interest in the band, and combined with that trippy cover art I prepared myself for a journey in the unknown.

This New York three-piece combine increasingly off-kilter riffs with supreme dissonance to create a work that's both somehow compelling yet inaccessible. The twin guitars (Mike Eber and Kirk Schoenherr) don't sound like any other guitars you've come across. Utilising odd time signatures and curious tuning, Smother Party are safely on the avant side of garde. Casa Limon is the bands first full length record since forming in 2007, and with the addition of drummer Sam Levin they've added a more complex dimension to their sound.

Their sound....well, it's difficult to describe. It's controlled madness. Rhythms gain momentum and fall away at the drop of a hat and it all seems a little bit odd. "Titus" has passages of extreme heaviness, it's hard to believe that such tones are coming out of a guitar (there's no bass here). There's what could possibly pass as a black metal riff hidden in there beneath the waves of crashing cymbals and the crescendo of disordered noise. But - it all makes perfect sense when you're enclosed with this record. Envelope yourself in waves of instrumental experimentation, whack this on your stereo, plug in your headphones and be carried away on looping tides of trance inducing discord.

"Perfidy" again blasts away any preconceptions you might have had when first beginning the record. The final minute or so wouldn't sound out of place on an orthodox black metal album. Lightning fast beats from the drums control the speeding guitar sound, mesmerising in it's intensity. Smother Party aren't abiding by any rules here, none more so than on "Ghost Games" which includes a beautiful mid-section reminiscent of post-rock influenced chords. The track finally descends into a jarring clash of cymbals and reverb and the closing seconds lead into "Memo 109," beginning with a militaristic drum beat and more of those post-style guitar flourishes.

Smother Party are certainly challenging. But sit back, relax, and let them induce a blissful state of confusion.

7.5 / 10 — Cheryl • November 14, 2011

Smother Party – Casa Limon cover artwork
Smother Party – Casa Limon — Variant, 2011

Recently-posted album reviews

Roky Erickson And The Aliens

The Evil One (deluxe edition)
Fire Records (2026)

I feel very fortunate to have seen Roky Erickson perform live at SXSW backed by Okkervil River in 2010 or 2011. Erickson passed away in 2019 at the age of 71. For those of you who aren’t already disciples, Roky Erickson was the lead vocalist of legendary Texas psych rockers 13th Floor Elevators. Recorded after the breakup of the Elevators … Read more

Mike D

Thank You
Capitol (2026)

Beastie Boys were a huge part of my transition from teenager into adulthood. An album for every stage of their growth musically matched the many chapters of my own personal development. Ad-Rock, MCA, and Mike D were like cherished friends for my earholes. The world mourned together when we lost Adam Yauch to cancer in 2012 and were heartbroken knowing … Read more

Softjaw

Love Can't Kill You
Bachelor Records, Dandy Boy Records (2026)

I already wrote about these dudes in my mid-year top 5 since Oakland’s Dandy Boy Records released a compilation of their early digital singles back in April, and here they are following it up with a 12-song album of all new material! This second release proves Long Beach’s Softjaw have a masters in powerpop from the school of rock. I’m … Read more