Review / 200 Words Or Less
Smoking Popes
Stay Down

Appeal (2008) — Sean K.

Smoking Popes – Stay Down cover artwork
Smoking Popes – Stay Down — Appeal, 2008

Can't say that I was too familiar with this band's music. But after seeing them at a recent intimate club show, I walked away convinced. A break-up of many years has done nothing to dull their songwriting chops. This record is brimming with catchy songs right from the first note. "Welcome to Janesville" kicks things off with a power pop punch, and everything after goes full tilt. By the time we get to the last song, the acoustic "First Time," I feel like I need a bottled water to pour over my head. Think if Morrissey fronted The Plimsouls and you may get a sense of what's on tap. Hopefully this release will push them out of the Midwest and into the nation's consciousness. Maybe someone in DC is a closet fan?

7.5 / 10 — Sean K. • February 11, 2009

Smoking Popes – Stay Down cover artwork
Smoking Popes – Stay Down — Appeal, 2008

Related news

Bouncing Souls Announce More Legs To Tour

Posted in Tours on June 10, 2025

Smoking Popes dates

Posted in Tours on January 4, 2025

Smoking Popes with Lovely Stuff

Posted in Records on November 26, 2024

Recently-posted album reviews

Various Artists

Tightwire / Canadian Rifle - Nietzsche
Red Scare Industries (2026)

Available in a black and white print gatefold sleeve, this is a 2-band, 6-song split 7". The gate fold is a nice touch to a classic split 7", complete with full lyric sheets. When the needle hits it's cleanly produced pop-punk in the vein of Lookout Records, built on crisp melodies and harmonies. While it's bright and sunny in sound, … Read more

Sweeping Promises

You Say I Romanticize
Sub Pop (2026)

What strikes me foremost about this record are the vocals. As the father of a 13 y.o. daughter I feel qualified to say that this person could be a pop singer. I mean I don’t really know what it takes to be one, although I’m sure that it’s more than a voice good enough to win a game show, I’ve … Read more

Moonraker

Me and the Bells
Punkerton Records (2026)

I have probably talked about this before, I knew of Moonraker through split EPs and things like that, but they didn't fully pop into my consciousness until The Forest. Me and the Bells, four years later, is their follow-up full-length and it continues the trajectory from that record while still capturing its own distinct vibe. Musically the band is heavily … Read more