Review
Roy
Big City Sin and Small Town Redemption

Fueled By Ramen (2003) Michael

Roy – Big City Sin and Small Town Redemption cover artwork
Roy – Big City Sin and Small Town Redemption — Fueled By Ramen, 2003

The whole "ex-members of" marketing campaign is starting to get out of control. The hype that surrounds these types of bands before they even release anything is ridiculous. What is the point of even reviewing them if all you ever hear is about is the artists' former endeavors? And with that question posed, I introduce you to the band Roy, whom already released three EP's on different labels since their inception, including the eye-opening Tacomatose EP on Initial Records last year.

Big City Sin And Small Town Redemption, the first full-length from the Tacoma, Washington natives, demonstrates their mastery of pop, alternative, indie and country music tones into a stunning success. Right from the start on "Something That's Real", the listener is greeted with fusion of tepid guitars and soothing melodies that bring to mind Built to Spill, and even mid-90's alternative legends The Meat Puppets at times. One song in and we're already golden. The subsequent three tracks are filled with lyrical hooks and seamless composition that sends the listener wandering through the lush woods of the picturesque Pacific Northwest. The folk-rock and country-tinged "Better Head North" is filled with soothing acoustic guitars and vocal melodies that draw influence from the likes of Neil Young and even Elvis Costello. The recipe of pop sensibility and indie-rock continues with the standout tracks "Prescription Drugs" and "Rebel Hymn", which find similarities to the works of The Weakerthans and ...Trail of Dead. Lyrically speaking the album is very diverse, moving from the whimsical "They Cut the Cord" to the serious-mattered "Never Getting Married". While there is plenty of experimentation in the songwriting, which distinguishes each song from each other, there still seems to be a small staleness. In particular, the go-between tracks can deter from the overall composition. Despite this minute flaw, Roy have quickly made the jump from promising to successful artist.

The determining factor for the majority of those interested in this band is going to be who they were prior to forming. It is refreshing to hear artists from a hardcore/metal background writing and performing music that is unique and transcends genres. But in the case of Roy, instead of living in the past, it may be more adventitious to reside here in the present.

9.0 / 10Michael • February 29, 2004

Roy – Big City Sin and Small Town Redemption cover artwork
Roy – Big City Sin and Small Town Redemption — Fueled By Ramen, 2003

Related features

Jeffrey Roy on ADR mixing and Andrei Tarkovsky’s "Stalker"

Regular Columns / Beyond Casual Observation • August 6, 2017

Royal Thunder

One Question Interviews • November 22, 2014

Destroy Nate Allen

One Question Interviews • December 27, 2013

Related news

Pig Destroyer in Australia

Posted in Tours on August 20, 2025

Samiarus’ Reign Destroyer

Posted in Records on March 27, 2025

Recently-posted album reviews

Action/Adventure

Ever After
Pure Noise (2025)

Chicago’s Action/Adventure have been grinding the pop-punk trenches since 2014. They have always played pop-punk like it still has something to prove because for them, it does. They went viral in 2020 on TikTok with their song “Barricades” by calling out the exact thing no one in the scene wanted to say out loud. The genre is full of white … Read more

217

In Your Gaze
Time To Kill (2025)

If you didn’t know, hardcore and punk are alive and thriving in Italy. When I come across bands from there, their scene never ceases to amaze me. Italy gave us Raw Power and Negazione in the ’80s, Slander and Strength Approach in the 2010s. Now 217 picks up that lineage with their own mix of fire and reflection by keeping … Read more

Ugly Stick

Absinthe
Hovercraft Records (2025)

Contrary to what I said on Vh1’s Behind the Music, Tim from Hovercraft is one of my favourite human beings. I suppose in some ways that’s not saying much but Tim plays in one of my favourite bands, I’m a fan of his art and on top of those two things and running a label, his day job is saving … Read more