Review
Piebald
Accidental Gentlemen

Side One Dummy (2007) Scottie

Piebald – Accidental Gentlemen cover artwork
Piebald – Accidental Gentlemen — Side One Dummy, 2007

I appreciate humor in music. Being a literary nerd, there's nothing more satisfying than catching a good pun or play on words in the midst of a steady rock beat. Unfortunately, little in today's music scene really delivers. Metalcore (a slowly dying dinosaur), and whatever you call it that Three One G puts out (art school grind-punk?) goes for the laugh but almost always misses. Their take on sharp humor mostly comes off as scathing irony that sounds more like bitter social commentary.

Looking at the larger acts, a lot of the dick and fart humor in music vanished with the departure of Blink-182, but their slapstick was replaced with snarky one-liners penned by the new pop-punk darlings, Fall Out Boy. While Pete Wentz's lyrics do contain elementary traces of wit, they aren't so much funny as they are "cute"; their humor is pretty limited to cracking jokes about boys and girls desperate to fit in and fall in love. With this said, there's little out there to give us a hearty chuckle along with some sweet jams; unless of course, you consider Piebald.

With their newest album in roughly three years, in comes Piebald encouraging us to shake our asses and rattle our brains a little. Leaving the issues of love and relationships for the youngsters to squabble over, these Bostonians decide to sing about life's simple pleasures, like riding your bike ("Roll On"), not becoming obsessed with success ("A Friend of Mine"), and everybody's favorite, transcendentalism ("Nature Wins"). Each song is poignant in a conversational way, sparing all the dressed up poetics instead adding just the right pinch of tongue-in-cheek humor.

WithAccidental Gentlemen, Piebald has almost totally eradicated the rhythm based power chord formula that composed a lot of their work on Big Wheel Recreation. Moving their sound towards a bigger, riff based sound you can really hear that Piebald has succeeded in what they were trying to accomplish with their last album, All Ears, All Eyes, All the Time. Sticking with the comparisons to their last album, it is clear to see that Travis Shettel has also learned to really use piano parts effectively in their song writing giving them the sound of both lite-rock while as well as the E Street Band.

Accidental Gentlemen proves that that Piebald is no longer the band you've come to know, but still the band you've come to love. And that's no joke.

8.8 / 10Scottie • January 29, 2007

Piebald – Accidental Gentlemen cover artwork
Piebald – Accidental Gentlemen — Side One Dummy, 2007

Related news

A Piebald Christmas

Posted in Records on November 12, 2019

Piebald gets vinyl reissue

Posted in Records on November 17, 2013

Recently-posted album reviews

Elway

Nobody’s Going To Heaven
Red Scare (2025)

There’s a specific kind of punk record that doesn’t try to inspire you, doesn’t bother offering solutions, and doesn’t pretend things are going to work out in the end. Nobody’s Going To Heaven is firmly planted in that tradition. Elway returns sounding less interested in rallying cries and more invested in documenting collapse as it happens. They cover every collapse … Read more

Heather The Jerk

Very Motorcycle EP
Goodbye Boozy (2025)

Heather The Jerk is a project from Madison, WI musician Heather Sawyer -- a scrappy punk band with garage and pop influences running rampant through the peppy, raw sound. This 4-song EP is called Very Motorcycle, released about a year after the Not Very Motorcycle tape. I have no idea what the phrase means, yet it sets a distinct mood. … Read more

Toys That Kill

Triple Sabotage
Recess (2026)

If you were lucky enough to catch Toys That Kill live last year, you were maybe treated to a set that included classic F.Y.P bangers like “Come Home Smelly” and “Jerkoff”. I made the trip down to Seattle to see them with Off With Their Heads specifically for this reason and was in no way disappointed. I had somehow managed … Read more