Review
Of Montreal
Satanic Panic in the Attic

Polyvinyl (2004) Heidi

Of Montreal – Satanic Panic in the Attic cover artwork
Of Montreal – Satanic Panic in the Attic — Polyvinyl, 2004

One of the most prominent acts to emerge from the Elephant 6 collective, Of Montreal originated from Athens, Georgia, and is fronted by vocalist and guitarist Kevin Barnes and features bassist Nina Barnes, guitarist/synthesizer Jason NeSmith, guitarist Bryan Poole, keyboardist Dottie Alexander and drummer James Huggins. Since their conception in 1997, the group has released several albums prior to the addition of Satanic Panic in the Attic to their catalogue. Of Montreal's brand of indie pop, which compiles their delicately expressive and endearingly childlike lyrics with their notoriously ambitious musical endeavoring, has put them on the map as one of the essential token bands for the genre. Their newest release is no different in terms of innovation, listenability and the other qualities that markedly identify the ensemble, but also presents itself as the most fully realized and consistent album to date.

The record opens with "Disconnect the Dots", which sets the pace with the incorporation of handclaps, dual guitar work, and oddly enough the organ to form a likeable and catchy, naturally psychedelic feeling. The track finds Barnes repeating the lyric, "Come disconnect the dots with me, poppet", a verse that, without the musical variation present, could get boring fast. The next song, "Lysergic Bliss" shines with a sweet and cascading melody and vocals that flow effortlessly alongside the climaxes and denouements. "Will You Come and Fetch Me" is an appropriate bridge to the disco-funk styling of "My British Tour Diary". "Rapture Rapes the Muses" is probably the most accessible track off the album, which begins with a racing beat that is inserted between choruses. "City Bird" is the most relaxed song, and is a welcome drone that prevents the songs from blending indistinguishably into each other. The pause doesn't last long though, "Erroneous Escape into Eric Eckles" picks things back up with a country feel. "Chrissie Kiss the Corpse" is a teasing number about necrophilia, "Your Magic is Working" is a sweet love song, "How Lester Lost His Wife" is rough enough to offset the sugary feel of the album, and "Vegan in Furs" has Barnes' vocal range extending itself more than usual across the disco channeling closer.

Personally, I really like this record, but I am partial to the band's previous albums as well. Someone who is unfamiliar with their work may feel more receptive to this album than its predecessors, due to its cohesiveness and straightforwardly pop tracks. But I could also see someone who has had their fair share of Beach Boys and '60s psychedelia being unable to stomach Of Montreal's saccharin-soaked repertoire. Regardless, Satanic Panic in the Attic proves to be a worthy buy for fans of the genre and at the very least, a worthy download for those who share distaste for them.

9.0 / 10Heidi • April 27, 2004

Of Montreal – Satanic Panic in the Attic cover artwork
Of Montreal – Satanic Panic in the Attic — Polyvinyl, 2004

Related news

of Montreal sings of Lady on the Cusp

Posted in Records on March 12, 2024

Deerhoof with Perfect Pussy, Of Montreal, more

Posted in Tours on January 9, 2015

Polyvinyl 4-track series, volume 2

Posted in Bands on November 12, 2014

Recently-posted album reviews

The Arrivals

Payload
Recess (2026)

It's been a short lifetime since the last Arrivals record, Volatile Molotov, but in many ways the new Payload picks up exactly where the last one left off. It straddles the mid-tempo punk spectrum while drawing influence from seemingly all realms of the rock 'n' roll cannon. I'd state that mod, power-pop, Brit Invasion, and even R&B are some of … Read more

UDDER

Self Titled
Depose Records (2025)

Some records feel like they were carefully constructed. Others feel like they were barely contained. Udder’s three-song 7” on Depose Records lands firmly in the second category with a short, strange burst of psych-leaning noise rock that feels less like a statement and more like something unearthed. That’s not far from the truth either. Originally formed in the early ’90s … Read more

Various Artists

Louder Than You Think: A Lo-Fi History of Gary Young & Pavement (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack)
Independent (2026)

Gary Young wasn’t just a drummer; he was a beautiful, unpredictable glitch poking a hole in the sky where other lovable misfits could enter and leave this universe they’d grace with their presence. While Hendrix kissed the sky, Young merely bit a hole right through it. While Pavement was busy inventing the 1990s slacker blueprint for the masses, Gary was … Read more