Review
Noise By Numbers
Over Leavitt

Jump Start (2011) Loren

Noise By Numbers – Over Leavitt cover artwork
Noise By Numbers – Over Leavitt — Jump Start, 2011

Noise By Numbers are a group of Chicago punk veterans, and Over Leavitt gives a nice first impression. The sepia-tinged sunset photo of an industrial district gives a relatable, down to earth feel. On the flipside there’s a photo of the band playing a house show. Sure, they’ve put their sweat equity into the scene, but there’s no sense of entitlement to their record. They still drive around in a van, put out records on small labels, and let their music do the talking. The band includes Dan Schafer (Screeching Weasel, Riverdales, Methadones), Jeff Dean (The Bomb, All Eyes West), Rick Uncapher (Textbook), and Jimmy Lucido (Light FM).

While Schafer’s name conjures Ramones-core, Noise By Numbers continue to distance him from such a stigma. The opener, “Song for Emily” utilizes familiar power chords, but the focus is on elongated vocals, mid-tempo rhythm, and melodic flow—all themes that carry throughout the record. If a comparison has to be dropped, think somewhere between the Methadones and recent Green Day. There’s an interest in using a pop punk foundation, but drawing it out with more complicated structures and predominant melodies, mostly coming from the frontman rather than through group vocals. The power chords are used mostly to give an energetic boost here and there. The idea works well, but sometimes runs out of gas after that 2:00-2:30 marker, where the bridges get repetitive and Schafer’s vocals can get monotonous. While the lead singer intent is admirable, his voice isn’t really suited to the task and a few call and responses mixed in would keep the energy levels up. Instead, songs with more emotive displays, as in “Swarm of Flies,” sparkle and fade without maintaining as much pull and the epic feel of “Yes, You” goes on just a little too long.

More range is shown in “Reaching for the Sun,” which separates from Schafer’s past, though there are hints of Dean’s other band, The Bomb. Overall, the band sounds much as one would expect with so many years in the Chicago scene: varied influences are at play, with distinct melody remaining the core element of the songwriting instead of bombastic aggression or buoyant singalongs. The songs rely on highs and lows, switching up tempos frequently (and without awkwardness), using tonal difference to express themselves. In “Radiate,” powerful chords play over Schafer’s mid-tempo vocals, giving a pent-up, contained feeling while the guitar is ready to burst. When the breakdown comes, it’s a fluid, emotional release rather than a cathartic blast.

As a whole, Over Leavitt isn’t a bad record. The songs are well crafted and the different nuances from the musicians mesh well. The downside mostly comes in form of monotony, as the drumming holds almost the same beat over the eleven songs and Schafer’s voice can feel droney. Fans of the members’ extended discography should be interested, but it just doesn’t leap ahead of the pack.

6.5 / 10Loren • October 24, 2011

Noise By Numbers – Over Leavitt cover artwork
Noise By Numbers – Over Leavitt — Jump Start, 2011

Related news

New EP from Noise By Numbers

Posted in Records on January 2, 2015

Noise By Numbers cover Jesus and Mary Chain

Posted in Bands on September 29, 2011

Noise by Numbers announce second album

Posted in Bands on June 25, 2011

Recently-posted album reviews

Dream Fatigue

No Requiem
Daze (2026)

There’s a particular tension that makes alternative rock compelling. I love the emotional push and pull between softness and eruption. On No Requiem, Massachusetts outfit Dream Fatigue thrive in that space, crafting a seven song EP that balances dreamlike melody with bursts of distortion and emotional urgency. Born from the creative partnership between drummer Matt Wood and vocalist Jonali McFadden, … Read more

The Went Wrongs

This Isn't What I Ordered
Transcendental Revolution (2026)

I'm not sure what's happening to me in middle age. I used to find samples clever and a nice change-of-pace technique on albums. But lately I feel like they interrupt instead of compliment what I'm hearing. This Isn't What I Ordered starts off really strong with fast, melodic and personalized punk over the first few songs. Then the sound clips … Read more

Spillings

Spillings
The Garotte (2026)

Spillings is a minimalist reconfiguration undertaken by two artists whose careers have been about genre deconstruction. The paths of Mathieu Ball and Liam Andrews have been running on parallel tracks, but both have been aiming for a similar endpoint. That is to strip down the heavy, experimental rock form, while at the same time retaining its destabilizing core. With Big … Read more