Review
My Heart to Joy
Seasons in Verse

Top Shelf (2009) Michael

My Heart to Joy – Seasons in Verse cover artwork
My Heart to Joy – Seasons in Verse — Top Shelf, 2009

Seasons in Verse is the debut full-length from Connecticut's My Heart to Joy. The band's first long player is the follow-up to the band's most recent EP, last years Virgins Sails. Seasons in Verse sees My Heart to Joy continuing to distance themselves from their more aggressive infancy and developing their songwriting talents towards intricate and complex indie rock.

Lead off track "Time Spent Breathing" sets things in motion with a two minute instrumental. The guitars bridge the gap between Explosions in the Sky and Small Brown Bike; meanwhile the rhythm section supplies a solid building pace, quickening as the song draws to a close. "Empty Homes" immediately follows with its quirky guitar noodling - think Fugazi or Minus the Bear (minus all the finger-tapping). Shouted vocals are sporadically placed throughout, never in a direct verse-chorus-verse structure though. Vocally, I am reminded of In Pieces' vocalist Scott Gibson - which is ironic as they were also from Connecticut. It's a shouted spoken yell - if that makes sense of all - and there is a slight roughness in the delivery, but for the most part its fairly straightforward.

As the album moves from track to track the band continues to meld post-hardcore, indie rock, and melodic punk influences into a single sound. The title-track combines equal parts The Get Up Kids and Braid. "Old Capitals" deviates from the norm with a very down-tempo middle section that is eventually accented by some stellar post-rock-esque guitar noodling.

And while the band does demonstrate are more subdued approach in their songwriting, there are still those hints and flourishes of the band's early screamo influences. "Giving My Hands Away" is a prime example of this. Additionally, "Thirstly Corner of the Forest" is an upbeat rock piece when compared to the bulk of the material of Seasons in Verse.

The album also includes a cover of Guided by Voices' "Goldheart Mountaintop Queen Directory." It's an interesting choice that highlights one of the band's less obvious influences, one not discernible on first listen. I've never been a huge GBV fan

but they've adapted the song quite well and its fits their arsenal.

My Heart to Joy has shown a lot of improvement since their last EP. They've continued to refine their sound and find their own niche within the world of music. There are still a few rough edges that need to be smoothed out - a bit more variation in the songs. With a few more upbeat/faster-paced tunes, it would improve the album's flow greatly. Seasons in Verse is definitely an album to check out if you're looking for music along the lines of At the Drive In, Small Brown Bike, or Texas is the Reason.

7.5 / 10Michael • May 31, 2009

My Heart to Joy – Seasons in Verse cover artwork
My Heart to Joy – Seasons in Verse — Top Shelf, 2009

Related news

My Heart To Joy Break UP

Posted in Splits on February 15, 2011

My Heart To Joy Tour

Posted in Tours on July 1, 2010

My Heart To Joy Tourdates

Posted in Tours on July 27, 2009

Recently-posted album reviews

Street Eaters

Opaque
Dirt Cult (2025)

Sometimes I'm surprised at how averse I am to change. Hearing that Street Eaters had expanded to a trio caused me more trepidation than I want to admit -- and, like most fear of change, it was all for naught. The band hasn't changed and they aren't spilling over with annoying guitar solos either. They just have a little more … Read more

Faulty Cognitions

They Promised Us Heaven
Dead Broke Records (2025)

On their debut, Somehow, We Are Here, Faulty Cognitions made their statement. This wasn't a garage-punk band in the style of the members' previous bands (Low Culture and Shang-A-Lang, among others). It's a guitar-first rock indie-punk band schooled by the college rock of the 1980s. This time around the transition has been so seamless that maybe the debut was a … Read more

The Penske File

Reprieve
Gunner Records, Stomp Records (2025)

I used to dislike punk music where people sing. And, well, I'm still not super fond of it but there is an exception to every rule. The Penske File are one of those exceptions and maybe it's because while they have a singer (as compared to a "vocalist"), it's still authentic and conveys that everyperson vibe I seek in the … Read more