Review
The Mimes
Plastic Pompeii

Lets Pretend (2021) Loren

The Mimes – Plastic Pompeii cover artwork
The Mimes – Plastic Pompeii — Lets Pretend, 2021

After all the bedroom pop to come out of quarantine, we finally have a band doing something new that sounds like a real record, not an experiment. The Mimes features Maura Weaver, John Hoffman, and Megan Schroer, who played together in Boys long ago, and more recently in separate projects such as Homeless Gospel ChoirOgikubo Station, and Vacation.

Fittingly, The Mimes sound a bit like all three of those bands. But it’s far more experimental in nature, even if they mask it well by layering melodic guitars, vocals, and synthesizer up front and mixing the weird bangs, clangs, vocal effects underneath.

This record feels like a journey -- or more accurately, a trip. It starts out upbeat and peppy: hopeful but cynical, then it turns into a mind trip with cyclical patterns, spaced-out effects and a feeling of despair. Toward the end, it’s just weird--with an upbeat twist. In other words, it’s the experience of being stuck inside with your toys taken away for too long. There are elements of insecurity, boredom, anger, frustration and more. The vibe is generally positive, with forward-pushing rhythms and tones to counteract those harsher emotions, but there is an underlying tension with some real downer moments that you feel more than you hear. At times it’s playful punk with some danceable beats. At others it’s warped carousel music and, in the title track and album closer, it’s almost anthemic singalong absurdity in homage to a Plastic Pompeii.

While the band themselves call this experimental, it’s not hard to listen to or to find the melodies. It doesn’t sound like three people playing with Casios. Instead they mixed the additional elements, whether it’s synthesizer, spoken word bits, drum machines or sound effects underneath the primary melodies. It’s texture rather than ambient tones or field recordings.

Plastic Pompeii is a grower. I was relatively indifferent on first listen but, now, it grabs me more on each play-through and it keeps circling through my head each time the record stops. It’s unique enough that it’s hard to pigeonhole for a specific scene or listener. I enjoy it as a fan of the aforementioned bands quite a bit, so that’s a starting point. Of their other bands, I personally hear the most similarity to Vacation’s less straight-forward songs. On a broader level, it’s DIY pop-punk with a lot of weird elements that might hit a mark for fans of spacerock or synth-y punk like the Spits -- but at times I get some No Wave tones and, at others, hints of groups like B-52’s or Le Tigre too. The Mimes debut shows that it’s often a good thing to buck convention and do something new.

8.0 / 10Loren • April 26, 2021

The Mimes – Plastic Pompeii cover artwork
The Mimes – Plastic Pompeii — Lets Pretend, 2021

Related features

Vacation

One Question Interviews / What's That Noise? • March 6, 2023

The Mimes

Interviews • May 15, 2021

Related news

The Mimes debut (Vacation, Mixtapes)

Posted in Records on February 14, 2021

Advertisement

DCxPC 2025

Recently-posted album reviews

Detention

Dead Rock ‘N’ Rollers
Left For Dead Records (2024)

Life ain’t so easy in the detention home- Dead Boys. Emerging from the underbelly of Jersey, made up primarily of three brethren. Raised on rock and roll and sipping from the chalice of early punk rock stalwarts like Da Bruddahs from Queens, Hey Ho! and the Pistoleros of Sexual Nature screaming banshees from across from the large pond. Thus forging … Read more

Nightfreak

Nightfreak
Big Neck Records (2024)

Semi-feral punk outfit NightFreak are back with a self-titled LP filled with breakneck riffs and 70s metal bombast. The Chicago group haven’t slowed down since 2022’s Speed Trials but they have filled out. NightFreak the album is lousy with warm back beats and melodic guitars; although, hardcore vocals and tight drums still reign supreme. Album opener “Blackout” is dead serious … Read more

Death By Unga Bunga

Raw Muscle Power
Jansen Records (2025)

I’m pretty sure I became aware of Mike Krol when The Whiffs posted about playing some shows with him. Krol is a bit of an anomaly. Not only is he on Merge and collaborates with Mac Superchunk- a dream scenario imo- but he’s also been elusive of my fan boy attempts at cold dm’ing him about stuff even tho we … Read more