Review
Islands
Return to the Sea

Equator (2006) Chris

Islands – Return to the Sea cover artwork
Islands – Return to the Sea — Equator, 2006

Islands is the kind of band that has the ability to suck you into their creative vortex and draw from you the emotions that they choose to illicit accordingly, all the while Return to the Sea remains very optimistic and upbeat. How could it not? If you are a follower of Islands leaders Nick Diamond and J'aime Tambeur (who recently left the band) then you will already know the type of music these musicians typically create. Formerly The Unicorns, who were popular for their imaginative but messy pop music, are now Islands and they seemed to have tuned their instruments this time.

The best way to describe the sound on Return to the Sea is a well concocted mixture of calypso, pop, and rock. The album has one unifying sound which is pleasing to the ears and piques the mind's interest, yet each song maintains a certain uniqueness by adding some other style of music to the mix. For example, on the track "Where There's A Will, There's A Whale Bone" the sound is reminiscent of Th' Corn Gang, another one of the Unicorns side projects in which popular MC's laid tracks over Unicorn's songs. Nearing the middle of the song it changes from the most dark natured track on the album to a hip hop song and just as fast as it made the change it returns back to the songs original state just soon enough to wrap it up.

On the opening track "Swans (Life After Death)" elements of progressive rock can be heard. The beginning opens up to a mysterious whistling and a soft melody, which soon takes the form of today's typical progressive indie song that creates a large build up to the point of bursting and crashes in through a whaling of melodies and crooning. What makes "Swans" more interesting than the average progressive song is the interesting twist of calypso on the progressive cliché. Kind of like Coke with Lime.

The track "Volcanoes" can easily be picked out as a song influenced by country with its speedy, unchanging, chug-chug beat amidst fiddles and a humorous story typical of Diamond and Tambeur. "Volcanoes" is the apocalyptic tale of a large active volcano emerging in Alaska, melting it, and creating a new, icier Argentina. The track ends with a satisfying crash of all the instruments utilized throughout the song.

Return to the Sea's diversity and ironic, witty storytelling deserve the music community's attention for a brief time. If they have a track record anything like their former projects than they will not be around for much longer, it would be a shame to let a band of such talent and range as Islands be missed. The thing that makes Return to the Sea really worth the time, exactly one hour to be precise, is that it's fun. Islands is an easy listen which makes it great to take with you in the car or play at a party. It can also be a creative endeavor if you're really interested and pay close attention. Return to the Sea is great because of it can be played to anywhere, anytime.

Although Tambeur, half of the brains behind the project, has already left Islands Diamond tells their audience they will continue to play on, "Islands are forever," he proclaims as we wishes Tambeur the best.

8.5 / 10Chris • June 15, 2006

Islands – Return to the Sea cover artwork
Islands – Return to the Sea — Equator, 2006

Related news

An early taste of Melonball

Posted in Records on November 19, 2025

Record Thieves spin a new one

Posted in Records on August 30, 2025

Curbside's double release day

Posted in Records on August 8, 2025

Recently-posted album reviews

Sahan Jayasuriya

Don’t Say Please: The Oral History of Die Kreuzen
Feral House (2026)

For those of us who spent the mid-to-late 1980s navigating basement community halls, churches, and loveable, armpit-smelling dive bars, the name Die Kreuzen was a permanent fixture on the punk rock radar. They were the sound of the Midwest underground --too fast for the goths to do their spooky Bela Lugosi "shoo the bats away" interpretive dance, too technical for … Read more

Sewer Urchin

Global Urination
Independent (2025)

There’s a fine line between crossover thrash that feels dangerous and crossover thrash that just feels like a party. Global Urination doesn’t bother choosing because it does both loudly and without apology. St. Louis’ Sewer Urchin have been grinding since 2019, and on their latest full length they double down on everything that makes the genre work. They give us … Read more

Ingested

Denigration
Metal Blade (2026)

For a band that built its name on sheer brutality, Ingested have spent the last several years refining what that brutality actually means. With their newest release, Denigration, the band finds that continuing evolution. They’re still punishing, still precise, but noticeably more controlled and deliberate in how it all lands. From the outset, the record makes its intentions clear. “Dragged … Read more