Review / 200 Words Or Less
Half Hearted Hero
Defining. Refining.

Set Sail (2009) Michael

Half Hearted Hero – Defining. Refining. cover artwork
Half Hearted Hero – Defining. Refining. — Set Sail, 2009

Massachusetts is obviously more well known for its metal and hardcore scenes, but they've also got a pretty substantial stream of pop-punk bands churning out the hits as well. Half Hearted Hero is one of the upstart groups part of this surge. And here they offer up their debut full-length, Defining. Refining.

Half Hearted Hero fall in that middle of the road area between the two battlegrounds of pop-punk music. They're not a bubble-gum pop-punk band ala Fall Out Boy or New Found Glory. And they're also not a traditional sounding band akin to Screeching Weasel or Descendents. The twelve songs that comprise Defining. Refining. land someplace much closer to the worlds of Osker, The Swellers, and Polar Bear Club

which I guess is melodic punk, or not? I can see why some might consider them of the bubblegum variety though as the vocals are fairly sugary. Though the occasional roughness and shouting is mixed in too. Cuts like "Meter? I Just Met Her!" are quite enjoyable. If I had to point out one fault it'd be that the album is fairly one-dimensional. I could use with a wider mixture of tempos in the music and a bit more vocal variety - even if its backups - to help break up the monotony.

Based on what I was told about Half Hearted Hero, I wasn't expecting much. But, to my surprise their performance here is much better than I expected it to be. Defining. Refining. is a decent debut effort.

6.0 / 10Michael • August 26, 2009

Half Hearted Hero – Defining. Refining. cover artwork
Half Hearted Hero – Defining. Refining. — Set Sail, 2009

Related news

Suburbia boxset

Posted in Records on December 13, 2014

Half Hearted Hero Prep Release

Posted in Records on June 1, 2009

Farewell Party Signs Half Hearted Hero

Posted in Labels on April 27, 2009

Recently-posted album reviews

Faulty Cognitions

They Promised Us Heaven
Dead Broke Records (2025)

On their debut, Somehow, We Are Here, Faulty Cognitions made their statement. This wasn't a garage-punk band in the style of the members' previous bands (Low Culture and Shang-A-Lang, among others). It's a guitar-first rock indie-punk band schooled by the college rock of the 1980s. This time around the transition has been so seamless that maybe the debut was a … Read more

The Penske File

Reprieve
Gunner Records, Stomp Records (2025)

I used to dislike punk music where people sing. And, well, I'm still not super fond of it but there is an exception to every rule. The Penske File are one of those exceptions and maybe it's because while they have a singer (as compared to a "vocalist"), it's still authentic and conveys that everyperson vibe I seek in the … Read more

Menace Ruine

The Color of the Grave Is Green
Union Finale Records (2025)

One of the most unique voices in extreme music, Menace Ruine stand out in their sonic evolution. The duo of Geneviève Beaulieu and Steve de la Moth started out in a raw, uncompromising fashion, merging black metal and industrial to create absolute havoc in Cult of Ruins and The Die is Cast. In the coming years, they would expand this … Read more