Review
Deerhoof
Milk Man

Kill Rock Stars (2004) Shane

Deerhoof – Milk Man cover artwork
Deerhoof – Milk Man — Kill Rock Stars, 2004

Deerhoof, never one to rest on their laurels, is back in 2004 with Milk Man. Things seem to be the same as always as the public wonders, "Can Deerhoof really top Apple O'?" The same question was asked this time last year except it was Apple O' being questioned if it could live up to Reveille.

The album's "concept" is one that fits the album well. It's a story of an incredibly weird creature that brings kids into his dreamland and keeps them there. Almost a Nightmare On Elm Street feel but, a little cuter. The artwork is equally as disturbing, with what Deerhoof wants you to think this creature to look like and with the music that follows this concept, it makes you think that illustration couldn't be more right.

Satomi Matsuzaki's vocals help keep the balance of a child-like innocence through this dreamland while Greg Saunier's drumming pops up to remind you this isn't Kansas anymore. The use of interweaving piano, gives the poppy songs a more sophisticated touch. Organs then sneak in with every minor chord imaginable and scare the hell out of you. On "Desaparecere", the use of a drum machine backs Matsuzaki while an electric piano plays lounge-esque chords. Saunier's drumming starts to match up with the drum machine and the song turns into a struggle between good and evil.

Not to say this album isn't flawed at all. While it hardly bares a scratch at all, "Dog On the Sidewalk" seems to be an oversight when looking at the record as a whole. Luckily, it only clocks in at 1:13 so you hardly notice it. Well, you'll definitely hear Matsuzaki saying "Dog on the sidewalk" over and over but other than that, it's like it's not even there. Think of it as an intermission.

Is this better than it's predecessors? The jury is still out on that. Whichever side of the fence it lies on, it's still a great record. Where does Deerhoof stand in the grand scheme of things? While this is going to be billed as a concept album, I look at it as an everyday battle for Deerhoof. They are not quite sure if they are a noise band or if they are a pop band and this couldn't be more evident with this CD. The concept seems to play as a curtain over this war between the two genres who want to claim Deerhoof as another casualty. Deerhoof manages to stay strong though and seems quite content fighting each one, with each passing day.

8.9 / 10Shane • March 15, 2004

Deerhoof – Milk Man cover artwork
Deerhoof – Milk Man — Kill Rock Stars, 2004

Related news

Looking for Deerhoof on Spotify?

Posted in Music News on July 2, 2025

A Deerhoof milestone and a solo record

Posted in Records on April 9, 2024

Deerhoof's first album in Japanese

Posted in Records on January 23, 2023

Recently-posted album reviews

Personality Cult

Dilated
Dirtnap (2025)

I had a hard time starting this review. I can’t help coming back to the fact that it sounds like Marked Men. It does, maybe intentionally so, as Dilated is the second of Personality Cult’s albums that is produced by Jeff Burke of Marked Men and Radioactivity. But I don’t necessarily like to say a band sounds like another band … Read more

Various Artists

Her Head's On Fire/Arms Like Roses - Split
Double Helix (2025)

Her Head’s On Fire (NY, NY) and Arms Like Roses (New Haven, CT) team up on this split 7” with two new tracks (one each band) of post-hardcore tunes that are both massive and melodic in their own distinct ways. "Universal" is the track from Her Head’s On Fire. Recorded by the band’s guitarist Jeff Dean, "Universal" came from the … Read more

Dead Bars

All Dead Bars Go To Heaven
Iodine (2025)

Dead Bars has a unique talent of taking the everyday, the experiences you see and live all the time, and shining a new light on them to make them personal and interesting. I've written about it before, yet it's my job to say this again and to make it interesting. It's what Dead Bars does, so it only seems fitting … Read more