Review
Dawn McCarthy and Bonnie “Prince” Billy
What The Brothers Sang

Drag City (2013) Scott Wilkinson

Dawn McCarthy and Bonnie “Prince” Billy – What The Brothers Sang cover artwork
Dawn McCarthy and Bonnie “Prince” Billy – What The Brothers Sang — Drag City, 2013


The Everly Brothers were a staple in my house musically when I was growing up back in the early ‘60s; they were one of the biggest duos around and were known for their soaring harmonies and fusion of the current country sound with rock and roll. They toured and recorded from the late ‘50s through the early ‘80s and amassed a staggering collection of songs in their catalog. It must have been a huge undertaking to sift through them and choose the ones that Dawn McCarthy and Bonnie “Prince” Billy re-interpret here on their new release What The Brothers Sang. The important point to remember here is that, while Dawn and Billy are fans of the brothers, they didn't want to attempt to duplicate the songs in their original format; rather they preferred to take a fresh look at the songs and melodies to bring them into the present to a new group of fans. 

Overall the album is chock full of gems chosen from their entire career such as the fabulous version Dawn and Billy put together of the song “Kentucky," a Karl Davis song (covered by Phil and Don in 1958) and a true gem in every the sense of the word. The harmonies performed by Dawn and Billy are the focal point of the meandering song. Another great song on the album is "Breakdown" written by Kris Kristofferson in 1971. The vocals here are ethereal in nature and the song flows beautifully giving it a completely different feel over the original.

"Empty Boxes" and "What Am I Living For" are two songs that, again, are drifting folk tunes that were meant to be done by these two. The combination of the lyrics and the talented musicians accompanying them on both songs is incredible. The upbeat version of "Milk Train" sounds completely fresh and new in this version, as does the old standard "Somebody Help Me." McCarthy does a great interpretation here and shows her vocal range, as does Billy in making this one rock from start to finish as it was originally intended to.

Much of the material on the album, such as "My Little Yellow Bird," "Devoted To You," "Its All Over," "Just What I Was Looking For," and "Omaha" work well in the overall scheme of the album, which is to bring some great forgotten songs from the early American Songbook back into the present with a laid back flow to them presented by a talented group of studio musicians and two of the best vocalists currently recording in this genre today.

Dawn McCarthy and Bonnie “Prince” Billy – What The Brothers Sang cover artwork
Dawn McCarthy and Bonnie “Prince” Billy – What The Brothers Sang — Drag City, 2013

Advertisement

DCxPC 2025

Recently-posted album reviews

Detention

Dead Rock ‘N’ Rollers
Left For Dead Records (2024)

Life ain’t so easy in the detention home- Dead Boys. Emerging from the underbelly of Jersey, made up primarily of three brethren. Raised on rock and roll and sipping from the chalice of early punk rock stalwarts like Da Bruddahs from Queens, Hey Ho! and the Pistoleros of Sexual Nature screaming banshees from across from the large pond. Thus forging … Read more

Nightfreak

Nightfreak
Big Neck Records (2024)

Semi-feral punk outfit NightFreak are back with a self-titled LP filled with breakneck riffs and 70s metal bombast. The Chicago group haven’t slowed down since 2022’s Speed Trials but they have filled out. NightFreak the album is lousy with warm back beats and melodic guitars; although, hardcore vocals and tight drums still reign supreme. Album opener “Blackout” is dead serious … Read more

Death By Unga Bunga

Raw Muscle Power
Jansen Records (2025)

I’m pretty sure I became aware of Mike Krol when The Whiffs posted about playing some shows with him. Krol is a bit of an anomaly. Not only is he on Merge and collaborates with Mac Superchunk- a dream scenario imo- but he’s also been elusive of my fan boy attempts at cold dm’ing him about stuff even tho we … Read more