Review
City States
Geography

Safety Records (2014) — Cheryl

City States – Geography cover artwork
City States – Geography — Safety Records, 2014

They say that good things come to those that wait and for City States and their main member Joel Ebner, it's certainly true. Ebner has spent many years creating and perfecting his debut - Geography - and after forming in 2008, City States first record finally saw the light of day earlier this year. Geography is a lovely little record, all bright shimmers and electronic affectations with Ebner's voice vulnerable and delicate at all the right moments. "Endless Sunlight" bounds on a light beat with Ebner's vocal laying over the guitar and synth sections in order to lift it above the instrumentation and give it life. Joel plays a majority of the instruments on the record himself but a little help comes courtesy of Mike Burmester on drums and Steve Lund taking control of keys and synths. The little touches that Lund brings are affecting and gives Geography a genuinely delightful atmosphere while Ebner sings songs of loss and hope - "To Remember" - but the shining luminoisty that underpins the tracks gives Geography a current of glowing belief that things may just be alright in the end.

"(For Dad)" is a soft, instrumental piece that harbours a deep sadness in its short time and leads into the melodic, melancholic "Uncharted Waters" with ease. The track builds slowly, layering samples over and over while Ebner's voice cuts through the sorrow with clean, simple lyrics that speak volumes of the promise of new starts. "I'm Always Somewhere Else" is reminiscent of James Blake's material - tripped out beats underneath a strong vocal - and the record as a whole is a lot more electronic than initially suggested. Ebner's influences include The Antlers, Brian Eno and Tortoise (the band's John McEntire mixed the record) and they certainly shine through, The Antlers in particular in the frailty of the music and its way of dealing with feelings of sudden loss and heartbreak. Sadly, Ebner's father died halfway through the making of the record and the heartache is interwoven into the very fabric of the songs.

Geography is a wonderful start for City States and for Joel Ebner one can only hope that his next musical endeavours aren't coloured with such sadness but that he uses it to move forward and to learn and grow.

7.5 / 10 — Cheryl • October 6, 2014

City States – Geography cover artwork
City States – Geography — Safety Records, 2014

Related features

City States

One Question Interviews • September 30, 2015

Related news

Recently-posted album reviews

Pete Shelley

Sky Yen
Cold Spring (2026)

I played this on Halloween to spook the trick or treaters. My wife thought it was weird which is probably why I thought it was perfect. It’s foreboding and a bit disorienting, like John Carpenter’s spooky synth scores but less rhythmic and more ambient like Brian Eno’s Discreet Music. It actually pre-dates both as it was recorded in 1974 while … Read more

21 BUM SALUTE

PARTY DOZEN
City Slang (2026)

ALBUM HIGHLIGHTS – “Mad Rooter”, “Full Powers”, “Captain Honk”, “The Stinking Rose”Despite its disarming title, 21 Bum Salute offers not just a delightful sonic din but a strangely convincing take on…wait for it: hunting music. Not the kind of hunting done by rich people in tweed jackets and flat caps, but the urban-jungle kind – set against the menacing backdrop … Read more

The Monsters

Off The Road We go
Voodoo Rhythm (2026)

After 40 years of knuckle-dragging, drooling, drop-kicking drudgery, Switzerland's premier exporter of underground electrifying neck bolts is back. The Monsters return with 12 tracks of raw noise that clearly demonstrate they haven't lost a fraction of their edge to their sharpened fangs—bubbling test tubes, popping corks, and setting off a series of small photopsia explosions of light right behind your … Read more