Review
Cheap Girls
Giant Orange

Rise (2012) Nick M.

Cheap Girls – Giant Orange cover artwork
Cheap Girls – Giant Orange — Rise, 2012

It takes approximately 30 seconds to decide whether or not Cheap Girls’ latest album, Giant Orange, is to your liking. The overall, upbeat feel of the album is firmly established within the first few lines of “Gone All Summer,” instantly pulling you into the downtrodden world of bassist/vocalist Ian Graham and co. and not letting up once throughout. Combined with guitarist Adam Aymor and drummer Ben Graham, Cheap Girls are immediately reminiscent of iconic alternative rock bands like Dinosaur Jr., comfortably riding a wave of high-strung riffs and melodic choruses.

Hailing from Lansing, Michigan, the trio joins an already extensive list of Midwestern rock bands hellbent on making the day-to-day a little less tedious and bleak simply through loud, abrasive rock ‘n’ roll. Produced by Against Me!’s own Laura Jane Grace, Giant Orange is more polished than Cheap Girls’ 2009 release My Roaring 20s, but still contains the anthemic choruses and driving verses notable of their sound. What it lacks in the raw feel of previous efforts is more than compensated for with how huge and overbearing Giant Orange sounds (no pun intended). Chugging along at a steady pace and clocking in at a little more than half an hour, this 10-song collection is about as energetic and fun as it gets.

In contrast to the bright and lively nature of the music, Graham carries a tone of frustration and helplessness in every track. “Hard to look alive when the past is so present,” is uttered before diving into the sweeping refrain on “On/Off Switches,” only a small sample of the bleak themes at work. However, it all blends into a cohesive, optimistic result in the end and shows how to make the best out of a past that just won’t leave you the fuck alone. Even the acoustic “Cored To Empty” and “If You Can’t Swim,” easily the fastest song on Giant Orange, don’t sound out of place and add a refreshing shift, while still maintaining the infectious sing-a-longs and undercurrent of rambling spirit.

Giant Orange is without a doubt Cheap Girls’ most consistent release to date. The 3 years in between full-lengths has culminated into one of the year’s best records that transcends labels of punk and rock and whatever the hell else the kids are calling music these days. With a live show that only brings an added element of bursting energy, Cheap Girls are well on their way to establishing themselves as another massive, proverbial footprint in the rock ‘n’ roll landscape. Giant Orange leaves only more to be desired from the Midwestern trio and it’ll be exciting to see what they come up with next. As Graham mentions over and over in the closing moments of the album, “we always think of the right way last.”

9.0 / 10Nick M. • November 26, 2012

Cheap Girls – Giant Orange cover artwork
Cheap Girls – Giant Orange — Rise, 2012

Related news

Cheap Girls rarities rec

Posted in Records on August 17, 2016

Restorations and Cheap Girls tour

Posted in Tours on January 23, 2015

Cheap Girls tour

Posted in Tours on September 29, 2014

Recently-posted album reviews

Silver Proof

Even If It Hurts
Independent (2026)

Some pop punk records feel made for playlists and algorithms. They’re polished into oblivion, emotionally vague, and afraid to get messy. Silver Proof clearly didn’t get that memo. The Buffalo trio’s debut full length, Even If It Hurts, leans heavily into the emotional core of early 2010s emo pop and melody while still sounding energized rather than nostalgic. Across the … Read more

Lice (Aesop Rock & Homeboy Sandman)

Vol. 4: Miami Lice
Rhymesayers (2026)

This EP released kind of suddenly, back in March, right before a bunch of stuff hit the fan in my life outside of SPB. Which means the EP felt sudden, but this review has been stewing for nearly three months with a lot of repeat listening along the journey. At eight songs in length, it's short but sweet, and as … Read more

Various Artists

There Is No Sun - A Tribute To Jay Reatard
Sonic Church (2026)

The late, great Jay Reatard was a prolific master of rock n roll gems. Whether it be with his earlier budget-punk act of his namesake, Reatards, his synth-punk projects Lost Sounds and Angry Angles, or his solo material as Jay Reatard, Jimmy Lee Lindsey Jr. was an incredible songwriter. Those aforementioned bands are just a smattering of units he’s been … Read more