Review
Broken Poets
Optimism in E Minor

Wordvendor (2006) — Kaveh

Broken Poets – Optimism in E Minor cover artwork
Broken Poets – Optimism in E Minor — Wordvendor, 2006

Broken Poets' lead singer/songwriter dynamo, Tim McDonald, is truly the voice of the average American male in that his songwriting, melodies, and vocal delivery are completely, uh, average. Just don't tell him that.

Nearly every part of this album feels equal parts contrived and self-important "" the album name (only two of the twelve songs are actually in E Minor), the guitar playing (a collection of sterile riffs that seem tailor-made for a VH1 Top 20 nod), and McDonald's painfully boring vocal delivery (think Counting Crows meets Xanax meets angsty-Myspace-teen-rocker). Worse than all that is the lyrics. The band's site boasts, "McDonald is not just writing from the heart but is consistently tapping into some mysterious source of inspiration." It continues, for nearly a page, about McDonald's "gift for poetically expressing an almost transcendent philosophical insight." Right. Insight like "everyone else has what I want, there's always something new, all I want is to be alone", from "The N and the R." Song of a world-weary broken bard, or whining of a thirteen-year-old girl whose mother just took away her cell-phone? Transcendent philosophical insight like this abounds throughout the album, most of it approaching gabba-gabba-hey levels of profundity.

Not to say the whole album is a loss. Quite the opposite, in fact, Russ Phaneuf's drumming is rich and explosive at just the right moments, and near-perfectly submissive at others. Classically trained Russian pianist Svetlana Antropova does what she can to add motion to the tracks, but with such an uninspired vocal/guitar combo drowning her out on most every song, it becomes nearly impossible to focus on her excellent fingerplay.

It's a shame that Phaneuf and Antropova, both seemingly excellent musicians, are stuck riding the coattails of a much less talented McDonald. This record, with the right frontman, could've been killer. As it is, the self-released copies of Optimism in E Minor are destined for a spot in McDonald's basement.

3.5 / 10 — Kaveh • May 30, 2007

Broken Poets – Optimism in E Minor cover artwork
Broken Poets – Optimism in E Minor — Wordvendor, 2006

Recently-posted album reviews

The Obits

Cake Shop
Outer Battery Records (2026)

After the breakup of Hot Snakes, frontman Rick Froberg (Pitchfork, Drive Like Jehu, Hot Snakes) moved to New York in late 2006. He joined up with Sohrab Habibion (Edsel) on Guitar/Vocals to form a band with a more ‘twangy’ surf/blues driven sound, moving away from the chaotic style of Hot Snakes. In 2007, Scott Gursky (Shortstack) joined on drums and … Read more

David Eugene Edwards

Mercurial Silence
Sargent House (2026)

David Eugene Edwards's 2023 full-length Hyacinth was a significant turn in his musical journey. Americana still defined much of the record's spirit, from the guitar lines and the song structures, but the backbone was forged in electronica. While this shift was sonically significant, it did not alter Edwards's existential and ritualistic interests. In fact it amplified these concepts, imbuing his … Read more

Nagusame

I Want To Leave
White Russian Records (2026)

Nagusame are not reinventing melodic metalcore on I Want To Leave. They wear their influences openly, and anyone familiar with Shai Hulud, Misery Signals, or early-2000s metalcore will hear them almost immediately. What keeps the EP from feeling like simple nostalgia is what Nagusame does with those influences, especially the guitars.The guitars are what stay with me when I Want … Read more