Review
Broken Gold
Recovery Journal

Volcom (2011) Loren

Broken Gold – Recovery Journal cover artwork
Broken Gold – Recovery Journal — Volcom, 2011

When a band names their record Recovery Journal it should come as no surprise that the dominant impression is one of earnestness. Broken Gold is the Riverboat Gamblers’ guitarist Ian MacDougall’s project, drawing from varied personal experiences with recurring themes of alienation, heartbreak, and addiction—some drawn from his experiences after his bicycle was hit by a car in October 2009, which left him with major injuries.

The band, a three-piece also consisting of drummer Richard Cali and ex-Riverboat Gamblers bassist Patrick Lillard, sounds very little like MacDougall’s other band. Broken Gold takes a decidedly British turn, with influences coming in the form of bands like the Smiths, the Clash, and Stone Roses. Songs like “Ambulance Faces” and “Locked Out” take a Britpop vocal delivery, but the guitar meanders, taking less of a rhythmic approach than any of the aforementioned bands. “Mirrors” is a ballad of sorts, slowing down the tempo and relying on an emotive delivery that shows glimpses of the Smiths, but pushing keys into the background and focusing on the guitar. With lyric passages like, “I looked in the mirror for a second/realized I didn’t like what’s in it” delivered in MacDougall’s gritty wail, the emotional side of his songs clearly shines through. Later, he pulls from the Replacements book of gritty honesty with a more direct rock’n’roll foundation in songs like “Message to a Friend” and “Snow Day.” In general, the guitar is Broken Gold’s foundation, with an emotive, wailing MacDougal clearing his throat and his chest while piling on heavy doses of his influences. His primary vocation clearly isn’t as a singer, but he holds his own and the gruff delivery adds to the honesty and longing behind the record.

Overall, the record isn’t that bad. MacDougall writes well-crafted songs with building energy and heartfelt emotion—the problem is that nothing really separates itself from the pack on Recovery Journal. That last paragraph dropped a lot of names, and few of them were members of the band. Especially given the personal implications of the record’s concept, it fails to grip or to paint much of a picture of the artist who created it.

5.5 / 10Loren • March 7, 2011

Broken Gold – Recovery Journal cover artwork
Broken Gold – Recovery Journal — Volcom, 2011

Related news

Broken Gold Sends You Spiraling With New Track

Posted in MP3s on February 6, 2024

2-song Nice Surprise

Posted in Bands on February 13, 2021

Advertisement

DCxPC 2025

Recently-posted album reviews

Detention

Dead Rock ‘N’ Rollers
Left For Dead Records (2024)

Life ain’t so easy in the detention home- Dead Boys. Emerging from the underbelly of Jersey, made up primarily of three brethren. Raised on rock and roll and sipping from the chalice of early punk rock stalwarts like Da Bruddahs from Queens, Hey Ho! and the Pistoleros of Sexual Nature screaming banshees from across from the large pond. Thus forging … Read more

Nightfreak

Nightfreak
Big Neck Records (2024)

Semi-feral punk outfit NightFreak are back with a self-titled LP filled with breakneck riffs and 70s metal bombast. The Chicago group haven’t slowed down since 2022’s Speed Trials but they have filled out. NightFreak the album is lousy with warm back beats and melodic guitars; although, hardcore vocals and tight drums still reign supreme. Album opener “Blackout” is dead serious … Read more

Death By Unga Bunga

Raw Muscle Power
Jansen Records (2025)

I’m pretty sure I became aware of Mike Krol when The Whiffs posted about playing some shows with him. Krol is a bit of an anomaly. Not only is he on Merge and collaborates with Mac Superchunk- a dream scenario imo- but he’s also been elusive of my fan boy attempts at cold dm’ing him about stuff even tho we … Read more