Review
Bonnie "Prince" Billy & Matt Sweeney
Superwolf

Drag City (2005) Pat

Bonnie
Bonnie "Prince" Billy & Matt Sweeney – Superwolf — Drag City, 2005

What an album cover! It's the kind that would fit perfectly with the whole music sounding like album cover mantra that makes for a great last resort when you can't really come up with a good description of the music within on your own. With enough embellishing, it can work for almost every album ever created. But alas, Will Oldham (employing his current nom de plume Bonnie "Prince" Billy) and Matt Sweeney (of Chavez and Zwan fame) have created an album full of brand new songs you've known your whole life that sounds more akin to listening to your most creepily enigmatic uncle talk to himself on his back porch than, say, slowly drowning after slicing your wrists.

Oldham himself is practically the personification of the American songwriter. His voice and songs are intensely personal, yet inviting and even warm at times. It's not difficult to imagine his work being hammered out on an authentic back porch with an acoustic guitar and an old hunting hound at his feet, which is more than most of his neo-folk contemporaries can say. There's an undeniable genuineness and sincerity throughout his material, especially 1999's macabre I See a Darkness and now Superwolf, arguably his finest record since the aforementioned chef-d'oeuvre.

The quasi-epic "My Home is the Sea" (as well as the lines, "I have often said/ that I would like to be dead/ in a shark's mouth") opens the album on a somewhat misleading note, easily more lighthearted (despite the morbid lyrics) and full-sounding than the rest of the album's stark, minimalist statements. The sharp twang of guitar that hits about halfway through the song is one of the album's finest and most memorable moments. From hereon in, Superwolf assumes a much more private, reserved form excepting the loud choral bursts in "Goat and Ram."

The phrase "achingly beautiful" sums up the rest of Superwolf pretty well. The songs drip pensive melancholia while eschewing melodrama, creating an uneasy atmosphere throughout its duration. Bittersweet harmonies and barely audible guitar lines contribute to songs that are paradoxically emotional and aloof at the same time. "Rudy Foolish" is remarkably poignant, containing one of Oldham's best vocal performances backed by Sweeney's exceptional sense of harmony. The sampled voice of a woman confessing her infidelity to a presumed husband towards the end of "Blood Embrace" lends an almost unbearably tense atmosphere to an already hushed, shadowy song.

Teaming up with Sweeney seemed to be the perfect career move for Oldham, an artist whose work fell into a bit of a slump after I See a Darkness. I trust that Superwolf will creep its way onto my best of 2005 list come the year's closing stages, even if it's nothing like the album cover.

8.5 / 10Pat • March 13, 2005

Bonnie
Bonnie "Prince" Billy & Matt Sweeney – Superwolf — Drag City, 2005

Advertisement

DCxPC 2025

Recently-posted album reviews

Detention

Dead Rock ‘N’ Rollers
Left For Dead Records (2024)

Life ain’t so easy in the detention home- Dead Boys. Emerging from the underbelly of Jersey, made up primarily of three brethren. Raised on rock and roll and sipping from the chalice of early punk rock stalwarts like Da Bruddahs from Queens, Hey Ho! and the Pistoleros of Sexual Nature screaming banshees from across from the large pond. Thus forging … Read more

Nightfreak

Nightfreak
Big Neck Records (2024)

Semi-feral punk outfit NightFreak are back with a self-titled LP filled with breakneck riffs and 70s metal bombast. The Chicago group haven’t slowed down since 2022’s Speed Trials but they have filled out. NightFreak the album is lousy with warm back beats and melodic guitars; although, hardcore vocals and tight drums still reign supreme. Album opener “Blackout” is dead serious … Read more

Death By Unga Bunga

Raw Muscle Power
Jansen Records (2025)

I’m pretty sure I became aware of Mike Krol when The Whiffs posted about playing some shows with him. Krol is a bit of an anomaly. Not only is he on Merge and collaborates with Mac Superchunk- a dream scenario imo- but he’s also been elusive of my fan boy attempts at cold dm’ing him about stuff even tho we … Read more