Review
A Day To Remember
And Their Name Was Treason

Indianola (2005) — Kevin Fitzpatrick

A Day To Remember – And Their Name Was Treason cover artwork
A Day To Remember – And Their Name Was Treason — Indianola, 2005

We've all done it - you mention a band unfamiliar to your friend and they'll ask "What does it sound like?" and being lazy North Americans we'll often reply with a barrage of noteworthy names just recognizable enough to wipe the inquisitive look from our hapless chum's face, and just obscure enough to retain "street cred" with the remainder of our peers.

Well, with A Day To Remember's debut album And Their Name Was Treason, it gets even easier to compare - now you can be as specific as you want: "Well, the verse is {insert band A here} and the chorus is all {insert band B here}." This method of describing an album is easy to do, but more often than not, does not make for a good album to describe.

...Treason starts off, surprisingly enough, much more aggressive than the emo stance the band appears to take in their photographs. So much so, that you wonder how this As I Lay Dying-style aggression can be played so effectively whilst gazing at your shoes. The answer hits as soon as the chorus kicks in - the most unabashed pop-punk hook-laden twaddle this side of a Warped Tour 8pm slot.

To call ADTR derivative would be an accurate statement. It would also be accurate to call their debut album a very frustrating listen. As such, there's really no reason why we shouldn't be hearing them on those newfangled alternative radio stations the kids are all listening to along with the ubiquitous Blink 41 and The Sum 182's.

It's all there - the eighth grade lovesick lyrics: "You're the one worth waiting for. You're all I've ever needed in this life" from "A Second Glance", or "Something's wrong and it's not me for once and I'll know you'll call me crazy" from "If Looks Could Kill". Granted, lyrics like this are always made funnier when the person singing them is trying to sound like Max Cavalera, but it doesn't really make them better. I assume these lyrics are the fault of singer Jeremy McKinnon, but as the liner notes state the songs were written by the band as a whole, the blame is harder to place. A wise old man named David Lowery once said "What the world needs now, is some true words of wisdom - like lala la la la la la lala." He was being ironic, but apparently not everybody got it.

Guitarists Neil Westfall and Tom Denney do a passable job - almost admirable considering the material they have to work with (or maybe not, as they apparently co-wrote it) and Bobby Scruggs' drumming is at times so sloppy, one wonders if he's a relative of an executive at Indianola Records. It's hard enough to find music that can even fleetingly be called original, but it's bands like A Day To Remember that remind us that we need to look a whole lot harder.

A Day To Remember – And Their Name Was Treason cover artwork
A Day To Remember – And Their Name Was Treason — Indianola, 2005

Related news

Four Chord Music Fest 10 in Pittsburgh

Posted in Shows on February 24, 2024

Self Help Festival in Philadelphia

Posted in Shows on August 31, 2014

Recently-posted album reviews

David Eugene Edwards

Mercurial Silence
Sargent House (2026)

David Eugene Edwards's 2023 full-length Hyacinth was a significant turn in his musical journey. Americana still defined much of the record's spirit, from the guitar lines and the song structures, but the backbone was forged in electronica. While this shift was sonically significant, it did not alter Edwards's existential and ritualistic interests. In fact it amplified these concepts, imbuing his … Read more

Nagusame

I Want To Leave
White Russian Records (2026)

Nagusame are not reinventing melodic metalcore on I Want To Leave. They wear their influences openly, and anyone familiar with Shai Hulud, Misery Signals, or early-2000s metalcore will hear them almost immediately. What keeps the EP from feeling like simple nostalgia is what Nagusame does with those influences, especially the guitars.The guitars are what stay with me when I Want … Read more

AIH

Self-Titled EP
Independent (2026)

EP HIGHLIGHTS – “McEnroe” & “Ten Speed”Hatching out of COVID boredom between friends down on NYC’s Lower East Side, drummer Doug Stern and vocalist-guitarist Brian Runk casually kickstarted AIH by jamming through some classic rock and early punk covers. It's a preference that’s made abundantly clear via their high-energy live shows and staple sound of sturdy guitar, memorable chant-driven hooks … Read more